Arbitration or Commercial Courts? How to Choose Your Dispute Resolution Path
General
Arbitration or commercial courts under Saudi law: compare cost, speed, confidentiality, appeals and enforcement, and how to draft your dispute clause.
Most months, a business owner sits in our office with a stalled project or unpaid invoice and asks: arbitration or commercial courts? We answer with a question. What does your contract say?
The uncomfortable truth is that the answer to arbitration or commercial courts was written years earlier, in a short clause both sides signed in a hurry. No written arbitration agreement, and the claim goes to the Commercial Court by law. Sign one, and you are bound to arbitrate.
So we treat "arbitration or commercial courts" as a negotiating decision made at signing, long before it becomes procedural. Here is how we would settle arbitration or commercial courts under Saudi law today.
In short: small local disputes usually belong in the Commercial Court, which costs less; technical, cross-border or reputation-sensitive ones belong in arbitration. Between those poles, arbitration or commercial courts is decided contract by contract.
The rules behind arbitration or commercial courts
Four texts govern arbitration or commercial courts:
- The Arbitration Law, Royal Decree M/34 of 24/5/1433H, with its Implementing Regulations.
- The Commercial Courts Law, Royal Decree M/93 of 15/8/1441H.
- The new Enforcement Law, Royal Decree M/237 of 3/11/1447H, which replaced the 1433H law.
- The 1958 New York Convention, joined by the Kingdom in 1994 with a reciprocity reservation.
A draft new Arbitration Law, posted on Istitlaa in September 2025, may also change details of arbitration or commercial courts.
Arbitration or commercial courts: when we recommend the court
Under Article 16 of their law, the Commercial Courts hear disputes between merchants over their business, plus company, bankruptcy and IP claims. Nobody pays the judge. Litigants pay judicial costs of up to 5% of the claim, capped at SAR 1 million, normally borne by the loser.
Judgments can be appealed, with a narrow objection to the Supreme Court, and most steps run online through Najiz. Those are real points for the court side of arbitration or commercial courts.
The Commercial Courts Law (Article 8) also requires settlement or mediation through Taradhi before certain claims are filed. We lean toward the court when the claim is small, rests on clean cheques or promissory notes, or needs a party who never signed the arbitration agreement. There, arbitration or commercial courts is hardly a contest.
Arbitration or commercial courts: when arbitration is the better call
The biggest thing arbitration brings to arbitration or commercial courts is that you pick who decides. In a construction delay claim, you want an arbitrator who reads a bill of quantities without waiting for an expert on every item. Parties also choose the language, seat and governing law, and hearings stay private.
Time matters too. Article 40 of the Arbitration Law requires an award within the agreed period or, failing that, within twelve months, extendable by six. The award is final: no appeal (Article 49), only annulment on exhaustive grounds (Article 50), filed within sixty days (Article 51). For clients who hate waiting, that finality often settles arbitration or commercial courts by itself.
The Saudi Center for Commercial Arbitration (SCCA) has applied updated rules since 1 May 2023, with a non-refundable SAR 5,000 registration fee. In large and international contracts, we find arbitration or commercial courts usually ends in favour of arbitration.
Comparison table: arbitration or commercial courts?
| Criterion | Arbitration | Commercial courts |
|---|---|---|
| Source of jurisdiction | Written agreement | The law itself |
| Who decides | Arbitrators the parties choose | A state-appointed judge |
| Duration | 12 months unless agreed otherwise | Depends on appeal levels |
| Cost | Institution and arbitrator fees | Judicial costs capped at SAR 1 million |
| Confidentiality | Usually preserved | Public hearings by default |
| Challenge | Annulment on exhaustive grounds | Appeal, then Supreme Court objection |
| Enforcement abroad | New York Convention | Treaties and reciprocity |
The table will not decide for you. The answer to arbitration or commercial courts shifts with whichever criterion you rank first.
How we settle arbitration or commercial courts with clients
Before drafting a dispute clause, we ask five questions that boil arbitration or commercial courts down:
- What is at stake? Fees can exceed a SAR 50,000 claim, and at that size arbitration or commercial courts is theoretical.
- Is it technical? The more complex the engineering or financial issues, the more arbitration or commercial courts tilts toward a specialist arbitrator.
- Are secrets involved? Partner disputes and trade secrets belong behind closed doors, so arbitration or commercial courts is settled in favour of arbitration.
- Where are the assets? If they sit abroad, an award is easier to enforce under the New York Convention, and that alone can decide arbitration or commercial courts.
- Who is the counterparty? Government bodies need the Prime Minister's approval to arbitrate unless a specific law allows it (Article 10); the Government Tenders and Procurement Law allows it with the Finance Minister's approval. Against a government entity, arbitration or commercial courts hangs on that approval.
When you draft the clause
- If your answer to arbitration or commercial courts is arbitration, name the institution, seat, language and number of arbitrators.
- We have seen contracts send disputes to court and to arbitration at once. That breeds a side fight over arbitration or commercial courts before anyone reaches the merits.
- If you require amicable settlement before arbitration or commercial courts comes into play, fix its length and proof. In a 1444H judgment, the Riyadh Court of Appeal treated that step as a procedural condition the claimant must prove.
- An unwritten arbitration agreement is void (Article 9), so never leave arbitration or commercial courts to a handshake.
FAQs on arbitration or commercial courts
Q1: I sued in the Commercial Court despite an arbitration clause. Will the case proceed?
It will be registered, but your opponent decides its fate. Article 11 of the Arbitration Law requires the court to dismiss the case if the defendant raises the arbitration agreement before any other request or defence. If the defendant argues the merits instead, the objection is lost, and arbitration or commercial courts has in effect gone to the court.
Q2: The award went against me. Can I appeal?
No. Article 49 allows only an annulment action, on grounds Article 50 lists exhaustively, such as a missing or void arbitration agreement or an improperly formed tribunal. A study of 967 judgments found Saudi courts keep to those grounds and do not revisit the merits. Anyone weighing arbitration or commercial courts must accept that finality, for better or worse.
Q3: Arbitration or commercial courts: which is cheaper?
It depends on size. Commercial Court costs slide from 5% to 2% of the claim, capped at SAR 1 million. Arbitration adds institution and arbitrator fees. Small disputes are usually cheaper in court; in large ones, arbitration can earn back its cost in time and expertise, which is the real trade-off in arbitration or commercial courts.
A last word
Ask us today, "arbitration or commercial courts?", and we will say: show us the contract. Then tell us what is at stake, what kind of dispute it is, where your opponent's money sits, and whether it must stay quiet. The answer usually follows.
Our advice: read the dispute clause first. Settling arbitration or commercial courts at signing is far easier than after the dispute starts.
References
- Arbitration Law, Royal Decree No. M/34 dated 24/5/1433H, Bureau of Experts at the Council of Ministers. Articles 9, 10, 11, 40, 49, 50 and 51.
- Implementing Regulations of the Arbitration Law, Council of Ministers Decision No. 541 dated 26/8/1438H, Ministry of Justice.
- Law of Commercial Courts, Royal Decree No. M/93 dated 15/8/1441H, official English translation, Ministry of Justice. Articles 8 and 16.
- Enforcement Law, Royal Decree No. M/237 dated 3/11/1447H, Umm Al-Qura Gazette. Articles 7, 9 and 65.
- Judicial Costs Law, Royal Decree No. M/16 dated 30/1/1443H, and its Implementing Regulations, Al-Eqtisadiah, 22 April 2022.
- Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (New York, 1958), accession of Saudi Arabia, 19 April 1994, UN Treaty Series vol. 1774.
- Umm Al-Qura Gazette, 21 drafts posted on the Istitlaa platform, including the draft Arbitration Law, 29 September 2025.
- Linklaters, New Arbitration Rules of the Saudi Centre for Commercial Arbitration, May 2023.
- Aceris Law, The 2023 SCCA Arbitration Rules, July 2023. Registration fee.
- Al Tamimi & Company, Mediation Guide to MENA: Saudi Arabia. Mediation before filing.
- The Legal 500, Saudi Arabia: Litigation. Appeals and public hearings.
- Al-Watan, analysis of 967 judgments in actions to annul arbitral awards (in Arabic).
- Okaz, the Government Tenders and Procurement Law and arbitration clauses approved by the Minister of Finance (in Arabic).
- Riyadh Court of Appeal, Judgment No. 4430561312 dated 18/10/1444H, reported in an article on drafting arbitration clauses in construction contracts.

